Skip navigation.
Home

identity

There was so much going on today re:identity in our class presentations--I sort of got to thinking about it during tophat1's presentation, of course, but then so many of the other presentations seemed to hang around the same theme.

One particular example of what I mean came up during a bird's presentation--

a bird was saying that, although she had been advised to "change the names" on her project again and again, it just felt totally wrong to write a story about her sister (for instance) and then claim its subject had a totally different name than her sister's. There was, for her, this profound link between person/personality and name/identity.

tophat1 was, in my very underdeveloped interpretation of her presentation, talking about how we could be anyone we wanted online--indeed, we could redefine our most basic characteristics: male --> female, caucasian --> black, human --> banana. As an online persona, we were, in some measure, able to reinvent ourselves--all by creating a screenname, or an icon, or an email address. Our new identities were wrapped up in a name or a picture.

And this was totally what a bird seems to have experienced--her family members' identities were wrapped up in their names.

I am my name in real life... I'm marmalade here... I'm another name to my best friend ... yet another to the high school calc teacher who couldn't figure out the difference between me and my sister.... And, indeed, different stories and different actions go with different names. I wonder if a bird's family-story-tree could really exist if all the "characters" (for lack of a better term) were abstracted from their real identities.... would her grandmother, by any other name, still have worn her fur coat around the US VI? Interesting to think about.

identity

Of course, just because we have chosen these different ways to identify ourselves (pictures, screennames, etc) doesn't mean that we're experiencing a different self. Rather it means, I think, that we are experiencing different parts of ourself that, because they are created by us, relate directly back to us.

Part of my point in the female pretending to be a male, for example, is that we cannot really do this. Before we get online, we are already articulated into a system of gender, race, etc that mediates any experience we may have of trying to occupy the "other" while online.

I remember Lulu linking to

I remember Lulu linking to an article earlier in the semester that mentioned chat-psychotherapy. The only way a therapist was able to get this critically shy kid to open up was by chatting with him online--he had a totally altered personality when mediated through a computer. I guess the question I'm posing is how people act differently when they can create a different identity, an "other" as you name it. Now I don't really believe that if you create an avatar of yourself as a banana you're really going to be/act/think like a banana when you're sitting in front of the computer. But I'm wondering how that different identity may lead you to act in a way that you wouldn't normally?

It's funny because I've

It's funny because I've experienced a lot of this...some of the people I talk to are completely different when I'm talking to them online, which can be weird because then all meaningful interactions between me and a friend happen online. When time spent face to face is filled with trivial kind of going-through-the-motions type of interaction, and time spent online is when all serious and honest conversation happens, then talking online starts to feel like I'm interacting with a person's "real" identity.